Overrated

5. Simple Minds
When I was coming of age, all the trendies in Glasgow were Simple Minds fans. They used to do five or six shows in a row at a licensed hall and you had to be 18 to get in. Scottish people have a bad habit of loving anything remotely Scottish that makes the big time (remember Sheena Easton?),and the Minds fitted that bill. I never understood what all the fuss was about. All their songs sounded exactly the same, their lyrics were mostly nonsense and they all had an annoying thumping bass line. Until the mid eighties, they were the classic indie style act. They didn’t sell much, but everyone wanted to go to their concerts and buy their T-shirts. They finally made it big in 1985 with Don’t You Forget About Me reaching #1 worldwide. When I came to live in Brazil in 1988, the Simple Minds wave was not far behind. By 1990, all the teens I was teaching were into them. Finally, their fans either grew up or caught on to the fact that they were releasing the same song over and over again. In the mid nineties they brought out an album that went nowhere. I don’t know if they are still going, touring the nostalgia circuit. I don’t care either. Definitely the most overrated band Scotland ever produced. Truly awful. And yet the Billy Sloans of the country never tired of giving them a leg up.
4. The Rolling Stones
People look back at the sixties (whether they lived through that period or not) and imagine or pretend they remember The Beatles and the Stones battling for number one or waiting to see who would sell out their tours fastest. Truth be told, there was no contest. The Stones had a few hits, notably Satisfaction, and a lot of sold-out shows. But the Fab Four sold far, far more records and it was really no contest. The reputation of the London boys only grew along with their longevity. Jagger and Richards were no match for Lennon and McCartney. The Stones could take a lineup change, The Beatles couldn’t, the Fab Four being THOSE fab four. But the Scousers split up; the Stones never did. Every year or two they would release a new album with a couple of good singles and a lot of fillers. The older they got, the more the media loved them. Good songs? A few. Brilliant? No way. Overrated? Sad to say so, but yes.
3. U2
I saw U2 for the first time in 1982 and since then there has been no stopping them. There was a summer festival that was broadcast on Channel 4’s The Tube either around Christmas, 1982, headlined by The Police and with U2 second on the bill. Bono gave interviews, prattled on about everything from ‘glossy wallpaper music’ in the charts to religion in Ireland. The press fell in love with them. At that time, they only had released two albums (Boy and October), both of which were full of the nonsense arty lyrics that were the norm in the early eighties. In June ’83, Live at Red Rocks was shown on the five-hour special of The Tube and propelled their new album, War, to the top of the charts. But it wasn’t until 1986, when they released the Joshua Tree, that the band became an international phenomenon. This album was good, at least side one was. Ever since, they have released a plethora of mediocre albums that, assuredly, have sold well but have never reached the heights of the mid eighties. Bono became the voice of everything from Amnesty International to protect mom and pop stores. They tour a lot and sell albums by the truckload, and yet I doubt that these albums will be remembered much in later years. A band that started out good, reached a high and lived on for political reasons. Overrated like hell.
2. The Sex Pistols
Simple Minds, the Stones and U2 at least put out what we could call music, and more than one offering of it. The Pistols never did. They had one album and a series of outtakes, sporadic singles and re-releases in a hundred packages, but Never Mind The Bollocks was their only real album. The band barely lasted two years before falling apart. Sid Vicious became the vocalist and a few money generating singles were released. The Sex Pistols were never meant to last long and the members themselves never seemed to take the project very seriously. And yet, as the years passed, they became something of an icon, which they didn’t deserve to be. Yes, in terms of image and shock TV there can be no doubt that they made an impact, but to hold them up on a pedestal as musical icons is a joke. But that is what’s happening. Whenever an ‘influential’ list of albums is published, their lone release is inevitably there. A couple of good punk songs, a lot of fillers and basically forgettable, NMTB is given far, far more credit than it ever deserved, and so is the band.
1. The Clash










